Is cTrader or MetaTrader 5 better for CFD trading?
Verdict
- For most UK CFD traders cTrader edges it on cost: at Pepperstone, our recommended broker for both platforms, Razor FX commission is $3.00 per side on cTrader against $3.50 on MT5.
- MT5 is the better choice if you already use MetaTrader expert advisors or want Pepperstone's Smart Trader Tools add-ons.
- Pepperstone offers both on all three UK accounts — spread betting, Standard and Razor — so you can try each without switching broker.
- Capital.com offers MT5 but not cTrader.
Neither platform is better for everyone. The useful question is which costs less for how you trade and which runs the automation you already have. We compare them as Pepperstone offers them to UK clients, since it is our pick and one of the few FCA-regulated brokers with both.
Short answer, and where to run either
Choose cTrader if you trade FX actively on a raw-spread account and want the lowest commission, or if you plan to write strategies in C#. Choose MT5 if you have MetaTrader EAs or indicators, or want MetaTrader add-ons. Pepperstone Limited (FCA 684312) offers both platforms on its spread-betting, Standard and Razor accounts, so the decision does not lock you in.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Head-to-head at Pepperstone UK
| cTrader | MT5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Razor FX commission (USD account) | $3.00 per side, $6 round trip | $3.50 per side, $7 round trip |
| Razor gold commission | $3.50 per side | $3.50 per side |
| UK accounts | Spread betting, Standard, Razor | Spread betting, Standard, Razor |
| Automation | cTrader Automate (C# cBots) | Expert advisors |
| Pepperstone add-ons | — | Smart Trader Tools |
| Copy trading | cTrader Copy built in (on Pepperstone's international site) | MetaTrader Signals (on Pepperstone's international site) |
How much the commission gap is worth
The $0.50-per-side difference matters only on a raw-spread account and grows with volume. Worked through on Razor EUR/USD in a USD account:
- 10 standard lots a month: $60 on cTrader vs $70 on MT5 — $10 a month.
- 100 lots a month: $600 vs $700 — $1,200 a year.
- On Standard or spread betting there is no commission on either platform, so the gap disappears.
- On gold the two platforms charge the same $3.50 per side.
When MT5 is the right choice
If you have paid for or built MetaTrader expert advisors, rewriting them for cTrader takes time and testing, and that cost usually outweighs a small commission saving. MT5 also gives access to Pepperstone's Smart Trader Tools, such as Trade Terminal and Correlation Matrix, and it is the platform Capital.com (FCA 793714) offers if you want a second account with guaranteed stops. cTrader, by contrast, suits traders starting fresh with automation, because cBots are written in C#, a general-purpose language.
What doesn't change between them
The broker behind the platform sets the protections. With Pepperstone in the UK, either platform gives you the same FCA-regulated company, the same retail leverage caps (1:30 on major FX, 1:20 on major indices and gold, 1:5 on shares), negative balance protection, and FSCS cover up to £85,000 for eligible clients. Neither platform at Pepperstone gives you a guaranteed stop-loss.
Sources
Published by Pepperstone and Capital.com.
Is cTrader cheaper than MT5?
At Pepperstone, yes on FX with a Razor account: $3.00 per side on cTrader against $3.50 on MT5. Gold costs $3.50 per side on both, and Standard accounts have no commission on either.
Can I use both cTrader and MT5 with one broker?
Yes. Pepperstone offers both on its UK spread-betting, Standard and Razor accounts.
Which platform is better for automated CFD trading?
cTrader if you are writing new strategies in C#; MT5 if you already have MetaTrader expert advisors. Pepperstone supports both, plus API trading.
CFDs and spread bets are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage; Pepperstone says 73.6% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading spread bets and CFDs with it. Consider whether you can afford to take that risk. Nothing here is investment advice.