我们用真金白银测试经纪商,然后公布真实数据。
市面上大多数经纪商测评是照着官网参数写出来的。MyBestBrokers 在每家经纪商开设真实入金账户,实测真正重要的指标:出金到底多久到账、伊斯兰账户到底收多少费用、监管牌照编号到底能否查证。每个数字都有时间戳、有证据,并可自由引用。
目前尚未发布任何实测出金时间。只有在真实提款请求从已入金账户发出、且到账时间被记录后,条目才会出现在此处。在此之前,表格仅显示经纪商自行公布的说法,并明确标注为「声明」。
出金实证台账
真实出金,从申请到到账逐笔计时,按经纪商、按渠道分类,每月更新。
伊斯兰账户审计
免隔夜利息账户的实际收费——与营销宣传逐项对照实测。
加密货币出金测试
哪些经纪商能稳定以 USDT/USDC 出金,链上转账实际多久到账。
我们有何不同
我们不凭主观印象给经纪商排名。我们真实入金,通过真实渠道(银行转账及 USDC/USDT)执行真实出金,在免隔夜利息账户上真实持仓过夜,并记录实际发生的一切。经纪商官方宣称与我们的实测结果并列展示、明确标注。即使合作经纪商测试结果最差,数据也照发不误。
| 经纪商 | 监管机构 | 最低入金 | EUR/USD 点差低至 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
ASICFCACySECDFSA | ASIC · FCA · CySEC · DFSA · SCB | $10 | 0.0 pips (Razor account, raw spread + commission from $3.50 per lot per side) | 立即开户 |
FCACySECCySECASIC | FCA · CySEC · CySEC · ASIC · SCB · CMA | $20 | 未公布 | 立即开户 |
FCASCBFSCCMVM | FCA · SCB · FSC · CMVM · BACEN · CSSF | $0 | 0.5 pips (standard Individual account — broker publishes "Trade With Spreads from 0.5 pips", commission-free; localized spread table shows EURUSD "as low as 0.5") | 立即开户 |
ASICFSA SeychellesFSCAFSC Mauritius | ASIC · FSA Seychelles · FSCA · FSC Mauritius · CySEC | $100 | 0.0 pips (Raw account, MT4/MT5/cTrader; commission US$3 per 100k lot each way); 1.0 pips (Standard account, zero commission) | 立即开户 |
CFTC / NFAFCAASICMAS | CFTC / NFA · FCA · ASIC · MAS · CIRO · Kanto Local Financial Bureau · BVI Financial Services Commission · KNF | $0 | EUR/USD from 1.0 pip (spread-only Standard account) or 0.1 pip + commission (Core pricing) — OANDA Global Markets (BVI), https://www.oanda.com/bvi-en/cfds/our-pricing/ | 立即开户 |
FCACySECASICADGM FSRA | FCA · CySEC · ASIC · ADGM FSRA · MAS · FSA Seychelles · FinCEN · SEC / FINRA · Gibraltar FSC | $10 | 1 pip (single retail live account; published "Currencies From 1 PIP — EUR/USD 1 Pips" at etoro.com/trading/fees/cfd-spreads/) | 立即开户 |
CySECFSCDFSA | CySEC · FSC · DFSA | $5 | "spreads as low as zero" (Zero Account); EURUSD-specific from-figure not published on public pages | 立即开户 |
FCAFCAASICASIC | FCA · FCA · ASIC · ASIC · BaFin · MAS | $0 | 0.5 pips (standard CFD/spread betting account); from 0.0 pips on EUR/USD with FX Active account + 0.0025% commission per transaction — https://www.cmcmarkets.com/en-gb/forex | 立即开户 |
Financial Conduct AuthorityCyprus Securities and Exchange CommissionSeychelles Financial Services AuthorityFinancial Sector Conduct Authority | Financial Conduct Authority · Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission · Seychelles Financial Services Authority · Financial Sector Conduct Authority · Dubai Financial Services Authority | $100 | 0.0 pips (Raw Account, $3 per lot per side); Classic Account from 1.6 pips, zero commission — published as account-level "Spreads From" on tickmill.com/trading/accounts-overview, not EURUSD-specific | 立即开户 |
ASICFCACIMAFSC | ASIC · FCA · CIMA · FSC · FSCA · VFSC | $50 | 0.0 pips (Raw ECN, + USD3.00 per lot per side); Standard STP from 1.0 pips, commission-free | 立即开户 |
按交易平台
按监管机构
- FCA 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
- ASIC 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
- CySEC 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
- DFSA 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
- FSCA 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
- MAS 监管经纪商:牌照编号,可自行核查
经纪商一对一对比
- ActivTrades vs Capital.com
- ActivTrades vs CMC Markets
- ActivTrades vs eToro
- ActivTrades vs Exness
- ActivTrades vs FP Markets
- ActivTrades vs FxPro
- ActivTrades vs HFM (HF Markets)
- ActivTrades vs IC Markets
- ActivTrades vs OANDA
- ActivTrades vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- ActivTrades vs Pepperstone
- ActivTrades vs Tickmill
- ActivTrades vs Vantage
- ActivTrades vs XM
- Capital.com vs CMC Markets
- Capital.com vs eToro
- Capital.com vs Exness
- Capital.com vs FP Markets
- Capital.com vs FxPro
- Capital.com vs HFM (HF Markets)
- Capital.com vs IC Markets
- Capital.com vs OANDA
- Capital.com vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- Capital.com vs Pepperstone
- Capital.com vs Tickmill
- Capital.com vs Vantage
- Capital.com vs XM
- CMC Markets vs eToro
- CMC Markets vs Exness
- CMC Markets vs FP Markets
- CMC Markets vs FxPro
- CMC Markets vs HFM (HF Markets)
- CMC Markets vs IC Markets
- CMC Markets vs OANDA
- CMC Markets vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- CMC Markets vs Pepperstone
- CMC Markets vs Tickmill
- CMC Markets vs Vantage
- CMC Markets vs XM
- eToro vs Exness
- eToro vs FP Markets
- eToro vs FxPro
- eToro vs HFM (HF Markets)
- eToro vs IC Markets
- eToro vs OANDA
- eToro vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- eToro vs Pepperstone
- eToro vs Tickmill
- eToro vs Vantage
- eToro vs XM
- Exness vs FP Markets
- Exness vs FxPro
- Exness vs HFM (HF Markets)
- Exness vs IC Markets
- Exness vs OANDA
- Exness vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- Exness vs Pepperstone
- Exness vs Tickmill
- Exness vs Vantage
- Exness vs XM
- FP Markets vs FxPro
- FP Markets vs HFM (HF Markets)
- FP Markets vs IC Markets
- FP Markets vs OANDA
- FP Markets vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- FP Markets vs Pepperstone
- FP Markets vs Tickmill
- FP Markets vs Vantage
- FP Markets vs XM
- FxPro vs HFM (HF Markets)
- FxPro vs IC Markets
- FxPro vs OANDA
- FxPro vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- FxPro vs Pepperstone
- FxPro vs Tickmill
- FxPro vs Vantage
- FxPro vs XM
- HFM (HF Markets) vs IC Markets
- HFM (HF Markets) vs OANDA
- HFM (HF Markets) vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- HFM (HF Markets) vs Pepperstone
- HFM (HF Markets) vs Tickmill
- HFM (HF Markets) vs Vantage
- HFM (HF Markets) vs XM
- IC Markets vs OANDA
- IC Markets vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- IC Markets vs Pepperstone
- IC Markets vs Tickmill
- IC Markets vs Vantage
- IC Markets vs XM
- OANDA vs Octa (formerly OctaFX)
- OANDA vs Pepperstone
- OANDA vs Tickmill
- OANDA vs Vantage
- OANDA vs XM
- Octa (formerly OctaFX) vs Pepperstone
- Octa (formerly OctaFX) vs Tickmill
- Octa (formerly OctaFX) vs Vantage
- Octa (formerly OctaFX) vs XM
- Pepperstone vs Tickmill
- Pepperstone vs Vantage
- Pepperstone vs XM
- Tickmill vs Vantage
- Tickmill vs XM
- Vantage vs XM
指南
- Forex trading tax by country: what the official rules actually say
- How to verify a forex broker licence — and the traps that catch people
- Leverage explained: why the same broker offers you a different cap
- Islamic (swap-free) accounts: what they really cost
- How much money do you actually need to start forex trading?
- Opening your first trading account: what to check, in order
- MT4 vs MT5 vs cTrader: what actually differs between them
- How forex spreads actually work — and why two published numbers rarely match
- Negative balance protection and segregated funds: two different protections
- ECN vs market maker brokers: what actually changes when you trade
- Demo vs live forex account: what a demo actually proves
- How forex broker withdrawals actually work
- Slippage and requotes: why your fill price isn't always your click price
- Forex trading hours: sessions, overlaps and when liquidity actually shows up
- Cent accounts explained: what actually changes versus a standard account
- Copy trading explained: what you are actually exposed to
- What is a lot in forex, and how position size actually works
- Fixed vs variable spread accounts: what you actually trade off
- What actually happens to your money if a broker fails
- Margin call and stop-out: the two thresholds that end a losing position for you
- Forex vs CFDs vs stocks: what you actually own, and what you don't
- Choosing a broker for gold trading: what actually differs from forex
- How broker comparison sites make money, and what to check before trusting one
- Regulated vs unregulated brokers: what regulation actually changes
- Choosing a broker for day trading: execution and cost, not headline features
- How forex brokers actually make money, and why it explains their terms
- Standard, Raw, ECN and Zero accounts: what the names actually mean
- How to spot a biased broker review in a couple of minutes
- Choosing a broker for mobile trading: what actually differs from desktop
- Automated trading: what a broker actually needs to support before you build on it
- How to evaluate a forex broker bonus offer before you claim one
- Crypto CFD trading vs buying crypto directly: what actually differs
- Self-directed trading platform vs full-service brokerage: the actual trade-off
- Business and corporate trading accounts: what actually differs from a personal one
- Pepperstone vs Capital.com: which one actually has the lowest spread?
- No-commission, low-spread brokers: comparing what's actually published
- ActivTrades alternatives: how Pepperstone and Capital.com actually compare
- Which currency pairs actually have the lowest spreads?
- Does your trading platform affect your spread?
- Pepperstone review: regulation, fees and the honest verdict
- Capital.com review: is it good? Regulation, fees and the honest verdict
- XM review: regulation, fees and the honest verdict
- HFM review: is HFM regulated? Licence check, fees and the honest verdict
- Crypto exchange vs broker: what's actually different
- Pepperstone vs Capital.com: execution, fees and regulation, not just spreads
- Why September–October is a reasonable time to open a trading account
- Open a trading account this week: the real checklist
- Lowest minimum deposit forex brokers, checked against their own pages
- Best forex brokers in the UAE, verified against each broker's own site
- Best forex brokers in Saudi Arabia, verified against each broker's own site
- PolySouq 预测市场:如何把比特币、黄金、外汇和足球当作概率来交易
按国家/地区
- Australia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Hong Kong可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- United Kingdom可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Singapore可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- China可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Thailand可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Mexico可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Taiwan可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- United Arab Emirates可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Germany可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- India可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Saudi Arabia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Malaysia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Turkey可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Mongolia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Kenya可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Colombia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Italy可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Vietnam可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Chile可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Peru可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Indonesia可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Argentina可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Qatar可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Kuwait可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Oman可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
- Bahrain可用的外汇经纪商:实证数据
