CMC Markets 对比 Octa (formerly OctaFX)
本对比完全基于两家经纪商各自公示的资料——牌照均已在官方注册系统中核对，条款均引自其官网原文，每一项说法都附有来源链接。
| 监管机构 | FCA · FCA · ASIC · ASIC · BaFin · MAS | CySEC · MISA · FSCA |
| 牌照编号 | FCA CMC Markets UK plc — Register No. 173730 FCA CMC Markets Investments Limited — Register No. 948126 ASIC CMC Markets Asia Pacific Pty Ltd — ABN 11 100 058 213, AFSL No. 238054 ASIC CMC Markets Stockbroking Limited — ABN 69 081 002 851, AFSL No. 246381 (stockbroking) BaFin CMC Markets Germany GmbH — Registernummer 154814 MAS CMC Markets Singapore — licence number not printed on cited page | CySEC 372/18 MISA T2023320 FSCA 51913 |
| 成立年份 | 1989 | 2011 |
| 最低入金 | $0 | $25 |
| EUR/USD 点差低至 | 0.5 pips (standard CFD/spread betting account); from 0.0 pips on EUR/USD with FX Active account + 0.0025% commission per transaction — https://www.cmcmarkets.com/en-gb/forex | from 0.6 pips, floating (OctaTrader and MT5 accounts, published as "spreads from 0.6 pips on popular pairs" — no EURUSD-specific figure published) |
| 杠杆 | FCA (UK): Published as margin rates rather than a ratio: from 3.34% forex, 5% indices and commodities, 20% shares and ETFs | |
| 海湾入金方式 | ||
| 交易平台 | Next Generation (CMC proprietary web platform), Mobile trading app, MetaTrader 4 (MT4, incl. WebTrader) | OctaTrader, MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5 |
| 经纪商官方宣称 | Withdrawals to a registered bank account requested before the cut-off time (4pm UK; 11am outside the UK) are processed the same day. Card withdrawals: some card issuers within an hour, others up to five working days. Standard bank withdrawals: UK domestic one to two working days; international three to five working days (subject to UK banking hours). No charges for card or standard bank transfer withdrawals. [数据来源] | Withdrawals usually take no longer than 3 hours. Per method: 1-3 hours to approve the withdrawal, then up to 5 minutes (cards), up to 30 minutes (crypto), or up to 1 hour (local banks) to transfer the funds. No fees or commission on our side whatsoever. [数据来源] |
| 出金方式 | Debit/credit card, Bank transfer | Visa/Mastercard cards, bank transfer / local banks (e.g. THB, IDR, MYR, NGN rails), Skrill, Neteller, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, Dogecoin, Tether USDT (ERC20), Tether USDT (TRC20) |
| 加密货币出入金 | 否 | 是 |
| 伊斯兰账户 | 否 | 是 |
| 我们实测 | 测试进行中 | 测试进行中 |
| 接受以下地区客户 | Australia, United Kingdom, Singapore, Germany, Italy, United Arab Emirates | Indonesia, Malaysia, Turkey, India, Thailand, Germany, Italy |
| 立即开户 | 立即开户 |
我们不在此评出胜负。两份记录并排陈列，是因为正确答案取决于你身在何处、交易什么品种，以及由哪个主体为你开户——这些表格里都写得清清楚楚。
按国家/地区
- CMC Markets + Octa (formerly OctaFX): Germany, Italy
- CMC Markets 是 / Octa (formerly OctaFX) 否: Australia, United Kingdom, Singapore, United Arab Emirates
- Octa (formerly OctaFX) 是 / CMC Markets 否: Indonesia, Malaysia, Turkey, India, Thailand
CMC Markets 和 Octa (formerly OctaFX) 哪个更好？
脱离具体情况谈优劣没有意义。请只比较与你相关的那几行：各家是否接受你所在国家/地区的客户、你会被归属到哪个主体和监管辖区、最低入金是多少，以及你实际会用的那条出金渠道走起来如何。
CMC Markets 和 Octa (formerly OctaFX) 哪个更安全？
安全与否取决于托管你资金的主体，而非品牌本身。两份记录都完整列出了各家公示的全部监管机构与牌照编号——先确认哪个主体服务你所在的国家/地区，再到该监管机构的官方注册系统核实这张牌照。