CMC Markets 與 Tickmill 比較
本比較完全建立在兩家經紀商各自公布的資料之上——牌照皆已於官方註冊系統比對，條款均引用其官網原文，每一項說法都附有來源連結。
| 監管機構 | FCA · FCA · ASIC · ASIC · BaFin · MAS | Financial Conduct Authority · Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission · Seychelles Financial Services Authority · Financial Sector Conduct Authority · Dubai Financial Services Authority |
| 執照編號 | FCA CMC Markets UK plc — Register No. 173730 FCA CMC Markets Investments Limited — Register No. 948126 ASIC CMC Markets Asia Pacific Pty Ltd — ABN 11 100 058 213, AFSL No. 238054 ASIC CMC Markets Stockbroking Limited — ABN 69 081 002 851, AFSL No. 246381 (stockbroking) BaFin CMC Markets Germany GmbH — Registernummer 154814 MAS CMC Markets Singapore — licence number not printed on cited page | Financial Conduct Authority FCA Register Number: 717270 Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission License number: 278/15 Seychelles Financial Services Authority License number: SD008 Financial Sector Conduct Authority License number: FSP 49464 Dubai Financial Services Authority Reference Number: F007663 |
| 成立年份 | 1989 | 未公布 |
| 最低入金 | $0 | $100 |
| EUR/USD 點差低至 | 0.5 pips (standard CFD/spread betting account); from 0.0 pips on EUR/USD with FX Active account + 0.0025% commission per transaction — https://www.cmcmarkets.com/en-gb/forex | 0.0 pips (Raw Account, $3 per lot per side); Classic Account from 1.6 pips, zero commission — published as account-level "Spreads From" on tickmill.com/trading/accounts-overview, not EURUSD-specific |
| 槓桿 | FCA (UK): Published as margin rates rather than a ratio: from 3.34% forex, 5% indices and commodities, 20% shares and ETFs | FSA Seychelles: 1:1000 dynamic — auto-steps to 1:500 / 1:100 / 1:30 as exposure grows; crypto starts 1:200 FCA (UK): Retail 1:30 (1:20 on indices and stocks) CySEC: Retail 1:30 · Professional 1:500 |
| 波灣入金方式 | ||
| 交易平台 | Next Generation (CMC proprietary web platform), Mobile trading app, MetaTrader 4 (MT4, incl. WebTrader) | MetaTrader 4, MetaTrader 5, TradingView, Tickmill Trader, MetaTrader WebTrader |
| 經紀商官方宣稱 | Withdrawals to a registered bank account requested before the cut-off time (4pm UK; 11am outside the UK) are processed the same day. Card withdrawals: some card issuers within an hour, others up to five working days. Standard bank withdrawals: UK domestic one to two working days; international three to five working days (subject to UK banking hours). No charges for card or standard bank transfer withdrawals. [資料來源] | Processing Time On Withdrawal: "Within 1 Working Day" for every listed payment method (min withdrawal $25, no withdrawal commission); crypto FAQ adds "We usually process crypto withdrawals within a few minutes to 24 hours" [資料來源] |
| 出金方式 | Debit/credit card, Bank transfer | Bank transfer, Visa/Mastercard (credit/debit card), Skrill, Neteller, UnionPay, Crypto (BTC, ETH, USDT, USDC — ERC20) |
| 加密貨幣出入金 | 否 | 是 |
| 伊斯蘭帳戶 | 否 | 是 |
| 本站實測 | 測試進行中 | 測試進行中 |
| 接受下列地區客戶 | Australia, United Kingdom, Singapore, Germany, Italy, United Arab Emirates | United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates, Germany, Italy, China |
| 開設帳戶 | 開設帳戶 |
我們不在此評定勝負。兩份紀錄並列陳示，是因為正確答案取決於你身在何處、交易什麼商品，以及由哪一個法人為你開戶——這些表格裡都寫得清楚。
依國家/地區
- CMC Markets + Tickmill: United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, United Arab Emirates
- CMC Markets 是 / Tickmill 否: Australia, Singapore
- Tickmill 是 / CMC Markets 否: China
CMC Markets 和 Tickmill 哪一家比較好？
脫離情境談優劣沒有意義。請只比較與你相關的那幾列：各家是否受理你所在國家/地區的客戶、你會被歸屬到哪一個法人與監管轄區、最低入金多少，以及你實際會使用的那條出金管道走起來如何。
CMC Markets 和 Tickmill 哪一家比較安全？
安全與否取決於保管你資金的法人，而非品牌本身。兩份紀錄都完整列出各家公布的所有監管機構與牌照編號——先確認哪一個法人服務你所在的國家/地區，再到該監管機構的官方註冊系統查證這張牌照。